Port strike: Can West Coast ports absorb East and Gulf Coast import volumes?
Re-routing shipments from the East and Gulf Coast ports to the West Coast can be time-consuming and costly, an expert explained
A strike by unionized dockworkers began Tuesday at East and Gulf Coast ports, raising questions about whether West Coast ports are a viable alternative destination for unloading cargoes.
Tens of thousands of dockworkers represented by the International Longshoremen's Association (ILA) went on strike Tuesday at ports from Maine to Texas after the union was unable to reach an agreement on a new contract with the U.S. Maritime Alliance (USMX), which represents port employers. It marked the ILA's first strike since 1977.
The strike by dockworkers at 36 East and Gulf Coast seaports could put about half of the country's import volume at a standstill – raising questions about whether shipments can be diverted to the West Coast.
Douglas Kent, executive vice president of corporate and strategic alliances at the Association for Supply Chain Management (ASCM), told FOX Business in an interview that while it makes sense to consider alternative destinations to mitigate risk, "The West Coast ports can't handle an additional 50% of goods coming through there."
PORT STRIKE WILL BRING ANOTHER HIT TO FARMERS, SAYS FORMER TRUMP OFFICIAL
"We have severe passage constraints through the Panama Canal because of the drought, so even that isn't always the answer," Kent said. "That's an additional week-plus shipment, assuming that there's no backlog on the other side. So the cost associated with the re-routing of a shipment is also not to be underestimated."
Kent explained that because East and Gulf Coast ports handle more shipments to and from Europe, while West Coast ports handle most of the trade with Asia, there are capacity and cost considerations that factor into decisions about re-routing shipments.
PORT STRIKE BY THE NUMBERS: NEW YORK, SAVANNAH, BALTIMORE EXPECTED TO SEE DISRUPTIONS
"I don't think we're going to see a lot of re-routing. I do think that the ports on the West Coast are preparing for some increase in volume associated with that. But their ability to absorb nearly 50% of the import volume is not even a remote possibility," Kent said.
"What they don't want to do is also inadvertently cause the strain on their own operation," he explained. "So I think you've got to also play that factor in mind in terms of any potential re-routing. They'll accept an acceptable volume that doesn't overstress their existing capabilities and upset their existing customer base because their customers that have been loyal to them and routing through them, they don't want to disrupt that."
In an interview before the start of the strike on FOX Business Network's "Cavuto: Coast to Coast," Port of Los Angeles Executive Director Gene Seroka said that "very few people win when it comes to situations like this. These workers have to get paid. The companies must continue to reinvest and bring cargo in, which creates jobs from Maine to Texas for this great union and their employers association."
Host Neil Cavuto asked Seroka about the timing of the port strike in advance of the holiday season on shoppers' ability to access in-demand products.
"The timing couldn't be any worse," Seroka said. "We're on the doorstep of the retail holiday season. And set aside the big box retailers for just a second, who had the wherewithal to advance cargo and bring it in through other ports and get their inventory set up. It's that small- to medium-sized business that I'm concerned with. Typically, they run these last 12 weeks before the holiday to make payroll and keep their businesses viable, that's what's at risk right now."
THE TAFT-HARTLEY ACT: WHY BIDEN COULD USE THIS LABOR LAW TO PREEMPT A PORT STRIKE
West Coast ports like Los Angeles, Long Beach, Oakland and Seattle-Tacoma are the major seaports that could be destinations for re-routed shipments. Port operators aren't expecting a significant impact.
"We anticipate little to no impact on Port of Oakland cargo operations should there be an East Coast dockworker strike," a spokesperson for the Port of Oakland told FOX Business.
Port of Long Beach CEO Mario Cordero told FOX Business in a statement that the port is "fluidly processing record volumes of cargo" and that the port is ready to respond if needed.
"We hope for a timely and mutually beneficial resolution for the contract covering the East and Gulf Coasts. However, should the need arise, we will depend on the close relationships we have developed with our partners in industry and labor to work to keep the supply chain moving, and the U.S. economy functioning," Cordero said. "We are prepared to activate our Business Recovery Task Force for the duration in the event of any disruption of cargo movement in this region as a result of work stoppages elsewhere."
GET FOX BUSINESS ON THE GO BY CLICKING HERE
The port strike could cost the U.S. economy upward of nearly $5 billion per day, according to an analysis by JPMorgan. Some of that would be recovered after the end of the strike and ports recovered to normal operations over time.
The 36 East and Gulf Coast ports that have been impacted by the strike collectively handle half of the seaborne imports to the U.S., with significant amounts of agricultural products and vehicle imports, as well as machinery, fabricated steel and precision instrument imports in the balance. Those ports are also significant hubs for exports of U.S. agricultural and pharmaceutical products.
FOX Business' Aislinn Murphy contributed to this report.
This story has been updated to reflect the beginning of the strike on Oct. 1